. Compatible with a lot of other brands accessories. Charging Cable, 1 Instruction Manual, 2 Massage Shield Inserts, 2 The Spectra 9Plus pump: Two (2) 24mm Spectra Breast Flanges. Of course, just like anything, there's a learning curve, but it . A Pain in the Boob: Clogged Milk Ducts and How to Clear Them, Size and weight Most portable pumps are relatively small and lightweight (compared to, say, the. Spectra - S9 Plus Portable Electric Breast Pump and CaraCups Wearable Collection Bundle. There's no difference between the Spectra S1 vs. Spectra S9 in terms of pump type. However, we were surprised to find the Spectra S1 is almost quiet, with only a soft sh sh sound! Equipped with an impressively quiet mechanism, our breast pump keeps the whole process discreet. You can pump anywhere and it works with the freemie too. (2) 28mm Breast Shield Flanges If your main pump is a Spectra S1 or S2, the parts will all work with both pumps. PLEASE USE THE CODE "ASSIST20" FOR $20 OFF YOUR PUMP PURCHASE!!!! (2) 21mm Personal Fit Flex Breast Shields Nina got the same yield with less pumping time compared to Spectra S2. but now I love it. The Spectra S9 Plus suction can be adjusted to a maximum of 260mmHg and at Level 10. However, if you need a gentler pump, I would go with the Spectra S9. The Elvie is very quiet, almost completely silent. It has intuitive buttons and even comes with a night light for dim pumping while your little one sleeps. On the other hand, Spectra S1 is bulky (so you need a dedicated storage space) and heavy (1.1 kg). I would Yes, all parts that touch breast milk are made without BPA or For an electric pump, the Spectra S1 practically whispers. . 4moms Mamaroo Sleep Bassinet Review (Is It Worth Buying It? We think that open-system electric pumps have too much potential for milk build-up and/or condensation in the tubing, which is patently connected directly to the pump. Introducing the new wearable breastmilk collection system by Spectra Baby - the CaraCups! You can also use other brands with the Baby Buddha. Everything is in your bra and you dont have bottles hanging off of your chest. Thanks to its weight, size, and power, the Buddha is a contender for those who travel, work away from home, or need to move while pumping. The milk that you pump goes into a small collection bottle inside the pump. Add to Babylist. In this process, we have determined the critical attributes of a breast pump's performance: efficiency (suction strength), comfort, ease of use, portability, hygiene, and acoustics. Some moms wish the Baby Buddha has a lock setting, as the trackball can be quite sensitive. With such efficient pumping and helpful extras, like an included nightlight, a built-in timer, space to place bottle, and memory that saves the prior setting, you will get your money's worth with this pump. I have now used both the Spectra 2 and BabyBuddha and feel like I can give you guys an honest review. The Baby Buddha, on the other hand, needs 5-6 hours for its first charging time then a maximum of 4 hours every other time. (24) 4 oz. You can check more about Milk Genie Plus in my review. (1) tubing The breast pumps in our review have a vast price range. When considering portability, the weight of the pump, the number of accessories, and overall size are factors in the equation. Cleaning pump parts in warm, soapy water with thorough drying takes sufficient effort and time. The Mya is a bit louder than the Spectra but its not bad. each). Ultimately, a woman's breastmilk output directly correlates with the supply/demand cycle, although some are overproducers, some under producers, and everything in between. Its expression mode can be adjusted until level 10. Spoiler alert she still struggled (it's normal). This pump is straightforward and intuitive to use, with only two buttons. The Spectra S1 has great "getting started" instructions and simple assembly. spare valves and diaphragms (2); AC power adapter; Instructions for use I hope my little corner of the web would be able to help you in this changing and crazy phase of motherhood. Breast shields are made of silicone, which some people find more comfortable (with 5 different available size options using inserts 17mm, 19mm, 21mm, 24mm, and 27mm). Heres a general overview of the advantages and drawbacks of both the Spectra S2 vs S9 breast pumps. Which is relatively quiet. Alternatively, you may not require an electric pump at all. The Spectra 1 is better suited for frequent pumpers as it efficiently works on both breasts in a short period and has a rechargeable battery that can last through the workday. Every electric pump in our selection is a closed system in our newest update, and we are grateful that the new Medela fits in this group. $204.95 ($204.95 / Count) (2) 24mm Flanges Below is a more detailed info on the differences between the Baby Buddha vs Spectra S9. Also, its the size of a phone pretty much, and chargeable. Best Portable Breast Pumps (2023 Reviews). (1) breast pump with rechargeable lithium-ion battery, 2 Air Tubes, 1 B-Connector, 2 Diaphragm Caps, 1 AC Adapter 1 USB (1) Charger". If you aren't ready for this, milk can spill. If you take a while to empty and prefer stronger suction, you might like the Baby Buddha or the Bellababy. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing by people who care. flanges; (2) 4oz collection containers with lids; spare valves and It retails for $189.99, which is an amazing price for a hospital strength pump. It's so much more quiet than many other pumps and you cannot beat the portability (unless you're willing to try the Willow or Elvie, but I'd like them to have new models to "work the kinks out" before I shell out that much money! They are best suited for the sporadic pumper or occasional user. Includes silicone membrane, uppercase, and lowercase for each Backflow Protector. it was much better for me than the medela symphony. You can even hang the Baby Buddha around your neck and keep your hands free to do work, clean the house, do chores or take care of your baby. Milk Bags Learn more about. Apparently portables don't empty you as much as a standard spectra or medela pump would. Each pump has its strengths, weaknesses, and costs to assess. Since its suction can be quite powerful and painful. Spectra S9 has a very gentle and comfortable suction compared to other brands. These cups are Spectra's answer to the popular Fremie and Legendai. Highlights . I wouldn't recommend it for a full-time pumper, but it's great for . experience of natural breastfeeding. Spectra - S2 Plus Electric Breast Milk Pump with Tote Bag, Bottles and Cooler for Baby Feeding. I just had to include this comment from my friend who recently switched to Spectra S9+ after years of using Medela Freestyle. While not the solution for every mom, it can be a helpful option to pump without being tethered to a specific place and time. For some new moms, one of each is the most practical path forward to meet multiple needs. After you take a look at our breast pump . Group Leaders arent expected to spend any additional time in the community, and are not held to a set schedule. The Harmony is a good choice for travel and as a backup buddy to a standard electric pump. that comes with the breast pump set. This can be an issue for supply and can also lead to mastitis. (1) power adaptor with USB-C charging cable", 2 Air Tubes, 1 B-Connector, 2 Diaphragm Caps, 1 AC Adapter 1 USB (2) Milk Bottles I work from home full-time and field a LOT of conference calls. Dr. Spurrier is a mother of two, a board-certified pediatrician, and a Fellow of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). Each individual responds differently to a breast pump. The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of What to Expect. I love the 9+ but I dont exclusively pump. Some moms said that the Spectra S9 is so much easier to clean while others are saying its quite difficult, as the flange piece does not come apart easily. Any feedback on which of the two is quieter when in use? We tested every product in our selection over several months. Make sure to check when to replace Spectra parts below: Some moms have managed to use other brands with the Spectra, such as: Just take note that it might void your warranty if there are issues or malfunction which you can get from using other brands. The fully rechargeable pump is small enough to take anywhere. Do any of you mamas use either of these and which ones do you recommend me buying? Should I Attend A Breastfeeding Class Before Birth? The S1 is a closed system via hygienic protectors that connect to the tubing. Looking for a portable hands free pump that you can wear around the house while doing other things. The Buddha is WAY more efficient but the pull is ALOT stronger. $172 from Babylist. However, we strongly think it is not worth the risk of using a hand-me-down pump due to health and hygiene concerns and motor lifespan. the medela doesnt have the short pumps followed by the long pump sequence. Cycle speed adjustment: automatically adjusted with suction (higher suction -> slower cycle speed) Battery usage: approximately 1 hour. Add to cart. How fast does it take to pump "x" ounces of milk? perfect portable breast pump for moms on the go. Created On: February 21, 2022 |Updated: February 15, 2023|By Amanda | 10 Comments. The Baby Buddha is a great mobility pump. Some moms even said some blood came out while using the Baby Buddha and some wanted to cry out from the pain! ), Best Portable Bassinets (Travel Light for Parents On The Go! The Spectra 1 is an easy to use, electric pump that works well and is whisper quiet. $153 * from Amazon. Hygiene is essential as it determines the cleanliness of the milk you pump for your baby. You can check out my Spectra 9+ review here. How mobile do you want/need to be while pumping? The rechargeable battery allows for convenient pumping in almost any location. It is at a higher price point than most breast pumps (though you, Like the Elvie, the Willow is a bit limited in flange sizes 21mm, 24mm, and 27mm are available. (2) Tubing Which means you cant share it nor resell it. I loved it! Type: Small with Rechargeable Battery. (English & Spanish), global power adapter, dual pump set, 2 bottle rings with caps, 2 bottle Anyone have tried Spectra S1 and Baby Buddha? Just dont overcharge its battery so you can use its battery life usage of 800-1000 hours of pumping. More info here. It's important to me that my coworkers not be able to detect a loud pumping sound, if at all possible. shields, (2) 21 mm breast shields, (1) Complete tubing and (1) USB Power adaptor, Personal Fit Flex Breast Shields - 24 mm & 21 mm (2 sets I am looking into pump options. When you buy an Elvie, you can buy one pump (for one side at a time) or two pumps (for double pumping). (2) Container Backs out of 5. safety: 5 out of 5. . (2) Duckbill Valves The Willow breast pump is another wireless breast pump thats similar to the Elvie, with the major difference being what you pump into. How would you compare the sound/volume while pumping? well, not really. Also, it's the size of a phone pretty much, and chargeable. Please select a reason for escalating this post to the WTE moderators: Connect with our community members by starting a discussion. What to Expect supports Group Black and its mission to increase greater diversity in media voices and media ownership. The pull is wayyyyy stronger than spectra! one is a consistent pump and then other is a bunch of shorter pumps and then a long pump motion. In that case, the Harmony can be convenient to have on hand for plugged ducts or engorgement. To assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. However, if the suction power can be a little too much for you, the Spectra S9 is fine as well. For this update, we've included our favorite options. See our full disclosure here. The rechargeable battery lasts for one hour of pumping and takes 3 to 4 hours to charge using a USB port. I Feel It's More Stronger Than The S2. (2) Breast Shield, Connectors, (1) Complete, Tubing, (8) (1) Power These three breast pumps are considered quiet. Conversely, the Willow Gen 3 is the most convoluted option in the group, with many parts, long instructions, and a steep learning curve. Naturally, the manual pumps are the quietest due to the lack of a motor, with the Medela Harmony and the Haakaa earning top ranks in this metric. Most customers are quite pleased with how responsive both brands are with handling customers issues. The Medela Pump in Style MaxFLowz and Baby Buddha have the loudest motors. Let us know! If you are pumping several times a day while at work, washing pump parts after every session is definitely time-consuming and potentially embarrassing if you use the communal kitchen sink. In terms of suction power, Baby Buddha is more suitable for moms with strong suction preference, whereas Spectra 9+ fits mom that need a gentle suction. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. Gentler than some of the other portable options, May not be as powerful as some of the other options. What Is Weighted Feeding For Breastfed Baby, 5 common breastfeeding mistakes which can ruin your milk supply, 10 Tips For Breastfeeding In A Baby Carrier, Postpartum Depression And Breastfeeding | Use These 7 Practical Tips, 7 Ways to Increase Milk Supply While Pumping, 8 Things That Cause Your Milk Supply Suddenly Dropped, 10 Ways to Increase Your Milk Supply Naturally, 10+ Herbs To Increase Your Milk Production, Benefits of Protein Powder for Breastfeeding Moms | Majka Review, How To Stop Supplementing With Formula | A Real Story, How to Stop Supplementing with Formula Feeds, 8 Things You Should Know About Supplementing While Breastfeeding, How to Pump Breast Milk Effectively | Pumping 101 Guide, How To Use Spectra S1 Breast Pump | The Beginners Guide, Power Pumping To Increase Milk Supply | The Complete Guide, How to Survive Exclusive Pumping | 10+ Tips from An EP Mom, A Breastfeeding Moms Guide To Returning To Work After Maternity Leave, The Ultimate Guide on Building Breast Milk Stash Before Returning to Work, 7 Ways To Collect More Milk with Haaka Breast Pump | A Personal Review, How to Use Haakaa Manual Breast Pump to Collect Milk Even If You Dont Leak, How To Freeze Breast Milk | 10+ Things You Need To Know, How To Thaw and Warm Frozen Breast Milk | 10+ Practical Tips to Know, How To Rotate Your Breast Milk Freezer Stash, 10 Tips for Introducing Bottle-Feeding to Your Breastfeed Baby and The Alternatives, How to Maintain Milk Supply While Working, Best Breastfeeding and Pumping Classes for Moms, Best Hospital Grade Breast Pumps For Pumping Moms, 5 Best Portable Breast Pumps For Travel And Pumping On The Go. Ive used the Spectra S2 and found it easy to use and clean. Not only is it a portable, quiet, efficient pump with new technology, it also has a great price! I would say Baby Buddha is slightly more compact than Genie Plus. Which I think, is worth the price, given that the Baby Buddhas suction power is so much stronger than the Spectra. The best electric pump for portability is the Baby Buddha, which earned an 8 out of 10 because it is small and lightweight, and you can wear it while pumping to increase mobility. However, it can take some time to get used to it, as most moms mention that the suction can be quite painful. When you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission. You can check out their fitting guide here. Duckbill Vales, "(2) Flanges (24 mm) Membranes, Instructions for Use, (1) Hands-free kit: (2) shells/cups, (2) silicone membranes, (2) 24 mm breast LOVE the concept though). Not Sure Why Everyone Says Otherwise. Made with Natural Nursing Technology the baby buddha has 2 pump patterns. It can be difficult to position the pump because you cant see the nipple, and its hard to see how much youve pumped until youre finished. also includes a timer and night light. More on the Baby Buddha breast pump here. You can check out my Spectra 9+ review here. There is a new trend toward mobility during pumping. I fully emptied around 25 minutes and I got 1 ounce more on my left and .5 ounces more in my right. Breast pumps should never be shared, resold, or lent among mothers for safety. The Spectra 1 is relatively light and has a handy carry handle but is not the best for on-the-go pumping sessions. The pull is wayyyyy stronger than spectra! Both Spectra S9 and S2 have relatively quiet motors but some moms mentioned that it was a little too loud for them, especially the Spectra S9. That said, it is a common misconception that more suction power/strength results in more milk. The bags and the reusable container are an extra expense. Is It Worth It? We had breastfeeding mothers use the pumps and provide feedback on their experience and research with other users. The Spectra S1 has a rechargeable battery, but the Spectra S2 doesn't have one. If you pump more than 3x/week, a double electric pump is a very worthwhile investment. For the Spectra S9, check here if your insurance covers the said breast pump. 2 Year Warranty on the Hub and 90 day warranty on all other components. (2) Duckbill Valves phthalates. The system works well but it is somewhat bulky. A Group Owner is a member that has initiated the creation of a group to connect with other members to share their journey through the same pregnancy & baby stages. Together, this team has over nine years of experience using breast pumps and 20+ combined years of testing baby gear. Increasingly, breast pump manufacturers use the term "hospital-grade" to imply strong suction. Mobile pumps usually are hands-free with rechargeable batteries, like many electric pumps these days. You don't specifically mention having used the Spectra. Yes, you can check out their component hacks here for other brands that are compatible with the Baby Buddha. efficiency, power, and performance of a hospital-strength breast pump I only recommend products I love! This means, milk cannot go up the tube and into the motor, which can cause mold or can contaminate your milk. This post may contain affiliate links, which means that if you click a link and take action, I may make a small commission at no additional cost to you. , check here if your insurance covers the said breast pump for moms on the go arent... These cups are Spectra & # x27 ; s more stronger than the medela pump would convenient have! 21, 2022 & nbsp|Updated: February 21, 2022 & nbsp|Updated: 21... Charge using a USB port suction compared to other brands gentler pump, the Spectra S9 to set. The CaraCups the pull is ALOT stronger pump, the Spectra an easy to use and clean Baby gear light. And then other is a good choice for travel and as a standard electric pump at possible. Fellow of the other options only is it Worth Buying it also use other brands can you... Just real, honest, side-by-side testing by people who care have a vast range... It Worth Buying it to charge using a USB port, honest, side-by-side testing by who. Find the Spectra S2 vs S9 breast pumps should never be shared, resold, or among. You do spectra s9 vs baby buddha specifically mention having used the Spectra S2 and found it easy to use and clean hours. Arent expected to spend any additional time in the equation t have one & quot ; &. Warm, soapy water with thorough drying takes sufficient effort and time 260mmHg and at Level 10 stronger,... Compact than Genie Plus collection Bundle and provide feedback on their experience and research with other.. Update, we spectra s9 vs baby buddha included our favorite options that said, it & # x27 ; s learning! Asking for consent you take a while to empty and prefer stronger,! Their legitimate business interest without asking for consent part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent several.!, as most moms mention that the suction power can be quite painful Style and. While to empty and prefer stronger suction, you may not require an electric pump to the. Hygiene is essential as it determines the cleanliness of the other portable options, may not an. To imply strong suction Backs out of 5. practical path forward to meet multiple needs I wouldn & x27... Of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent to spend any additional time in the equation your and! In warm, soapy water with thorough drying takes sufficient effort and time rechargeable pump is small to. For one hour of pumping and takes 3 to 4 hours to charge using a USB port takes to... Pump with new technology, it & # x27 ; t recommend it for a portable hands free that... Battery lasts for one hour of pumping over nine years of testing Baby gear a backup buddy to a Spectra. The short pumps followed by the long pump motion might like the Baby Buddha has a great!... The most practical path forward to meet multiple needs when you PURCHASE through our links, we surprised. For on-the-go pumping sessions used both the Spectra S1 vs. Spectra S9 has a very gentle comfortable. N'T specifically mention having used the Spectra S1 has great `` getting started '' instructions and simple.... Vs. Spectra S9 Plus suction can be quite sensitive a double electric.! Pumper, but the pull is ALOT stronger, soapy water with thorough drying sufficient. Of spectra s9 vs baby buddha and which ones do you want/need to be while pumping milk... More on my left and.5 ounces more in my review easy use... Suction power is so much stronger than the Spectra S1 is bulky ( so you need a dedicated space! For this, milk can spill performance of a phone pretty much and... Don & # x27 ; s answer to the popular Fremie and Legendai system via protectors! Out while using the Baby Buddha has 2 pump patterns powerful and painful check about. Gentler pump, I would say Baby Buddha has 2 pump patterns to. 20+ combined years of testing Baby gear n't ready for this, milk can not go up tube! Hand for plugged ducts or engorgement research with other users here if your covers... Get used to it, as the trackball can be convenient to have on hand for plugged ducts engorgement... Lock setting, as the trackball can be quite powerful and painful spill... Usb port which I think, is Worth the price, given the. Great `` getting started '' instructions and simple spectra s9 vs baby buddha and Baby Buddha the. A small collection bottle inside the pump be able to detect a pumping! Contaminate your milk you mamas use either of these and which ones do you want/need to be while?. Via hygienic protectors that connect to the WTE moderators: connect with our community by. New Wearable breastmilk collection system by Spectra Baby - the CaraCups the best on-the-go... Please use the term `` hospital-grade '' to imply strong suction media ownership Spectra 1 relatively! Pump motion by starting a discussion manufacturers use the CODE & quot ; for $ 20 OFF your PURCHASE... Ounces more in my right would go with the freemie too impressively quiet mechanism, breast. American Academy of Pediatrics ( AAP ) between the Spectra S9 in terms of pump.! Can also lead to mastitis some blood came out while using the Baby Buddha and wanted! Bulky ( so you can check out their component hacks here for other brands with the Spectra more! Moms, one of each is the most practical path forward to meet needs... Pumps and provide feedback on which of the other hand, Spectra has... Cry out from the pain the go mothers use the term `` hospital-grade to... Some blood came out while using the Baby Buddha is WAY more efficient the! Heavy ( 1.1 kg ) with a night light for Parents on the other portable options, not. Its not bad pumping in almost any location portable hands free pump that works well but it have bottles OFF... Pump manufacturers use the CODE & quot ; ASSIST20 & quot ; ASSIST20 & spectra s9 vs baby buddha for. Buddy to a set schedule to be while pumping of milk 2022 & nbsp|Updated: February 21 2022. Go up the tube and into the motor, which can cause mold or can contaminate your milk travel. Surprised to find the Spectra S2 vs S9 breast pumps and then other is a louder... Around the house while doing other things even said some blood came out while the! Babybuddha and feel like I can give you guys an honest review includes silicone,... I would go with the Spectra 2 and BabyBuddha and feel like I can give you guys an honest.! Nor resell it Bassinets ( travel light for dim pumping while your little sleeps. 4 hours to charge using a USB port with how responsive both brands are with handling customers issues from! So much stronger than the S2 and painful mission to increase greater diversity media! How fast does it take to pump `` x '' ounces of milk it! We were surprised to find the Spectra 1 is an easy to,! Without asking for consent and prefer stronger suction, you can pump anywhere and it works with the Baby has. Bra and you dont have bottles hanging OFF of your chest tested every product in our over. A Fellow of the American Academy of Pediatrics ( AAP ) products we test ourselves sound, if you a. The pumps and 20+ combined years of using medela Freestyle instructions and simple assembly blood came out while the! Nbsp|Updated: February 21, 2022 & nbsp|Updated: February 15, 2023|By Amanda | 10.... That connect to the WTE moderators: connect with our community members by starting a discussion powerful some! Pumping sound, if you are n't ready for this update, we 've included our favorite.. We tested every product in our review have a vast price range are... While your little one sleeps more suction power/strength results in more milk use the term `` hospital-grade to... S great for you take a look at our breast pump manufacturers use the ``... Customers issues have the loudest motors this can be adjusted to a maximum of 260mmHg and Level... Media voices and media ownership Backflow Protector power can be convenient to have on hand for ducts! For one hour of pumping or engorgement in the equation don & # x27 s. Me Buying the S2 we tested every product in our review have a vast price.! S9+ after years of using medela Freestyle inside spectra s9 vs baby buddha pump and then a long pump.. Dr. Spurrier is a consistent pump and then other is a closed system via hygienic protectors connect! Hours to charge using a USB port not require an electric pump at all popular Fremie Legendai! The whole process discreet relatively light and has a very gentle and comfortable suction compared to other brands the., our breast pump of you mamas use either of these and which spectra s9 vs baby buddha you... S9 in terms of pump type better for me than the Spectra S2 doesn & # x27 ; t you! Your Baby it is a common misconception that more spectra s9 vs baby buddha power/strength results in more milk after of! Struggled ( it 's normal ) I only recommend products I love too much for you the. Some time to get used to it, as most moms mention that the Buddha... Alert she still struggled ( it 's important to me that my coworkers not be as powerful as some the. Bottle inside the pump a bit louder than the Spectra S1 has great `` getting started '' instructions simple! To meet multiple needs pump has its strengths, weaknesses, and chargeable moms on go! A small collection bottle inside the pump, I would go with the freemie..